Trying to decide between a combi vs conventional boiler? This guide breaks down the key differences, covering efficiency, space, installation, and suitability for different home sizes so you can confidently choose the right heating system for your needs.
Combi Boiler vs Conventional Boiler: Which Is Better?
What is a Combi Boiler?
A combi boiler stands for a combination boiler. It is a compact unit that functions as both a heating system and a water heater. These modern combi boilers heat water on demand using a heat exchanger that quickly warms water from the mains supply.
This design eliminates the need for separate hot water tanks or cylinders, freeing up valuable space in your home. Imagine the convenience of having both your heating and hot water needs met by a single, space-saving combi boiler system.
The compact nature of combi boilers makes them particularly suitable for urban homes and smaller spaces where every square meter counts.
A combi boiler simplifies the heating system by eliminating the need for a separate hot water cylinder and cold water tank, reducing installation complexity and costs.
This efficiency and convenience make combi boilers a popular choice for many homeowners looking to upgrade their central heating system and create a compact system.
Advantages of Combi Boilers
- Space-saving design – Compact units that don’t require a hot water cylinder or cold water tank, making them ideal for smaller homes.
- Instant hot water – Provides hot water on demand, so you never run out during use.
- Energy-efficient – Heats water only when needed, reducing heat loss and helping to lower energy bills.
- Simpler installation – Requires fewer components than conventional boilers, making installation quicker and less disruptive.
Disadvantages of Combi Boilers
- Limited simultaneous use – May struggle to supply sufficient hot water to multiple taps or showers at once, which can be an issue in larger households.
- Dependent on water pressure – Performance is affected by mains water pressure; low pressure areas may experience inconsistent flow.
- No backup hot water – Unlike conventional systems, combi boilers don’t come with an immersion heater, so there’s no alternative heat source if the boiler fails.
While combi boilers are highly efficient and convenient, they aren’t the best fit for every home. That’s why the debate between system vs combi boilers remains a key consideration for homeowners choosing the right system.
What is a Conventional Boiler?
Conventional boilers, also known as regular boilers, operate using a cold water tank and a hot water cylinder. These systems are well-suited for larger households with high simultaneous hot water demands, as they can store and supply hot water to multiple outlets at once, ensuring a reliable hot water supply.
For busy households with multiple bathrooms, a conventional boiler system can ensure hot showers for everyone in the morning without running out of hot water.
However, the space requirements for conventional boilers are significantly higher than those for combi boilers. The need for both a hot water cylinder and a cold water storage tank means that you will need sufficient space to accommodate these components.
Despite these space requirements, conventional boilers are highly efficient in homes with a traditional heating system and varied heating needs. This makes them a reliable choice for larger homes.
At Future Heat, we’re your trusted local experts for boiler installation in Newcastle and across the North East.
Get a free, personalised quote today for a combi or conventional boiler—and let our experienced team recommend the perfect setup for your home.
Pros of Conventional Boilers
- Great for high water demand – Ideal for larger homes with multiple bathrooms, as they can supply hot water to several outlets at the same time without pressure drops.
- Backup hot water source – Often include immersion heaters, allowing access to hot water even if the boiler breaks down.
- Stable pressure and temperature – Maintains consistent flow and temperature across multiple taps and showers simultaneously.
- Supports multiple outlets – Perfect for households with simultaneous hot water needs.
Cons of Conventional Boilers
- Lower energy efficiency – Especially older models, which may have reduced efficiency compared to modern combi boilers.
- Bulky system requirements – Requires both a hot water cylinder and cold water tank, which take up considerable space.
- Heat loss potential – Stored hot water can lose heat over time, leading to energy wastage.
- Longer installation time – Typically more complex and time-consuming to install compared to combi boilers.
Combi Boiler vs Conventional Boiler: An In-Depth Comparison
The primary difference between combi and conventional boilers lies in their design and operational mechanics. Combi boilers require only one compact unit, while conventional boilers necessitate a unit, a hot water cylinder, and a cold water feed tank.
This fundamental difference translates into varying space requirements, with combi boilers being much more space-efficient.
Installation complexity also sets these two types apart. Combi boilers generally have a simpler and quicker installation process due to their compact design and fewer components.
However, conventional boilers require more extensive installation efforts, including significant modifications to existing pipework. This complexity can increase both the time and cost associated with installing a conventional boiler.
Another key difference is how these boilers generate and deliver water pressure. Combi boilers rely on electrical or gas mechanisms to generate water pressure, while conventional boilers use gravity.
This means that the performance of a combi boiler can be influenced by the mains water pressure, potentially leading to inconsistent hot water delivery.
On the other hand, conventional boilers, with their separate storage tanks, can consistently supply hot water to multiple outlets simultaneously.
Heating and Hot Water Delivery
When it comes to heating and hot water delivery, combi boilers and conventional boilers operate quite differently.
Combi Boilers
Combi boilers heat water directly from the mains supply, ensuring that hot water is available instantly whenever you need it.
This on-demand heating reduces energy waste, as there is no need to store hot water in a tank. Imagine turning on the hot water tap and having a steady stream of hot water flow out immediately.
Combi boilers’ on-demand heating mechanism can result in lower energy expenses and more efficient water heating.
Conventional Boilers
Conventional boilers, on the other hand, store hot water in a storage cylinder for later use. While they can supply hot water to multiple outlets simultaneously, there may be a delay if the stored hot water is depleted.
The presence of a hot water cylinder allows conventional boilers to handle high simultaneous hot water demands effectively. For larger households, this consistent supply can be a significant advantage.
However, one of the drawbacks of conventional boilers is the potential for heat loss from the stored water in the tank. This can lead to increased energy consumption and higher energy bills.
Installation Considerations
Installing a boiler is a significant investment, and understanding the installation considerations for both combi and conventional boilers is essential.
Combi Boilers
Combi boilers are easier to install in smaller spaces due to their compact design and the absence of additional storage tanks.
This simplicity often translates to lower installation costs and reduced labour time. For urban dwellers with limited space, combi boilers offer a convenient and space-saving solution.
Conventional Boilers
Installing a conventional boiler can be more complex and costly. Conventional boilers require both a cold water tank and a hot water cylinder, which can increase installation complexity and space requirements.
Additionally, significant modifications to existing pipework may be necessary, further complicating the process and increasing installation costs.
Homeowners should weigh these factors when choosing the type of new boiler to install.
Space and Storage Requirements
Space and storage are critical factors when choosing between combi and conventional boilers.
Combi Boilers
Combi boilers are designed to be compact and eliminate the need for separate storage tanks, making them ideal for homes with limited space.
Without the need for a hot water cylinder or cold water storage tank, combi boilers can be installed in smaller areas, such as a kitchen cupboard or an airing cupboard.
Conventional Boilers
Conventional boilers require more space due to the need for both a hot water cylinder and a cold water storage tank. This means that homeowners need to have sufficient space to accommodate these components, which can be a challenge in smaller homes.
However, for larger homes with ample storage space, conventional boilers can be an effective solution.
Efficiency and Cost Comparison
When comparing combi and conventional boilers, efficiency and cost are two critical factors.
Combi Boilers
Combi boilers generally lead to lower ongoing costs, making them more economical for homeowners. They provide hot water on demand, which reduces heat loss and potential energy savings.
Conventional Boilers
Conventional boilers, while effective in supplying hot water and heated water to multiple outlets, may have higher energy consumption due to heat loss from stored heating water, which can cause them to lose heat.
Energy Efficiency
Energy efficiency is a significant consideration when choosing a boiler.
Combi Boilers
Combi boilers typically achieve an efficiency rating between 90 and 94 per cent, significantly reducing energy waste and lowering energy bills.
A high-efficiency combi boiler can save up to 30% on annual energy bills, leading to substantial savings over time. Modern combi boilers are designed to minimise heat loss, making them a more energy-efficient option compared to older heating systems.
Conventional Boilers
Older conventional systems may operate at around 55% efficiency, leading to higher energy consumption and increased heating bills. Switching from an old boiler to a modern, efficient combi boiler can save homeowners approximately £340 annually on energy bills, especially when replacing an old heating system.
Thus, energy efficiency is a big factor to consider when choosing between combi and conventional boilers.
If you’re ready to start saving on your energy bills, request a free combi boiler installation quote today. At Future Heat, our expert team will help you choose the most efficient setup for your home and handle the entire process with ease.
Initial and Long-Term Costs
The initial and long-term costs of a boiler system are also essential considerations.
Combi boilers generally have a lower purchase price compared to traditional systems, making them a more cost-effective option.
The cost range for converting from a conventional boiler to a combi boiler is between £3000 and £4000, which includes the cost of the boiler and installation. However, the elimination of the need for a hot water cylinder can save homeowners between £600 and £1,000.
In the long term, combi boilers typically have fewer components, leading to lower maintenance costs and potential savings. They also come with a warranty period of 10 to 12 years, ensuring peace of mind for homeowners.
While the initial cost of a conventional boiler can be up to £2,750, the potential savings on energy bills and lower maintenance costs make combi boilers a more economical choice.
Performance Analysis
Performance is a critical aspect to consider when choosing a boiler.
Combi Boilers
Combi boilers may struggle with multiple taps or showers operating simultaneously, leading to reduced performance.
This limitation can be a significant drawback for larger households with high simultaneous hot water demands. However, for smaller homes, combi boilers provide sufficient hot water on demand, making them an efficient choice.
Conventional Boilers
Conventional boilers, on the other hand, are designed to heat one lot of water at a time efficiently, making them suitable for larger households. They can maintain a steady flow and temperature, even during peak usage times.
This consistent performance makes conventional boilers a reliable option for homes with multiple bathrooms and high hot water demands.
Maintenance and Lifespan
Regular maintenance is pivotal for ensuring the longevity and efficiency of both combi and conventional boilers.
Combi Boilers
Combi boilers usually last between 10 and 15 years, depending on usage and maintenance.
Annual servicing is essential to check for leaks and ensure all components are functioning properly. Regular maintenance includes checking for limescale buildup, which can significantly decrease a boiler’s lifespan. Factors such as frequency of maintenance, installation quality, make, and model can all affect the lifespan of a boiler.
Conventional Boilers
For conventional boilers, regular maintenance is often more critical, as the systems involve more parts that can fail. A major maintenance requirement for regular boiler systems is an annual check-up by a heating engineer.
Checking that all components are functioning properly and identifying potential issues can extend the lifespan of conventional boilers.
Proper maintenance can help avoid costly repairs and ensure the boiler operates efficiently throughout its lifespan.
Fuel Types and Compatibility
Combi and conventional boilers can use various fuel types, including natural gas, oil, and LPG. The majority of homes in England, Scotland, and Wales utilise gas boilers, making them the most common choice. Natural gas is a popular and cost-effective fuel type, offering high energy efficiency for both combi and conventional boilers.
In Northern Ireland, more than 66% of households utilise oil boilers that come with a storage tank requiring periodic refilling. LPG boilers serve as a viable option for homes not connected to the gas grid, though they tend to be more expensive than gas and oil.
When choosing a boiler, consider the availability of fuel types and the potential for joining purchasing groups for discounts. This can help ensure that your heating system is both efficient and cost-effective.
Should You Replace Your Conventional Boiler with a Combi Boiler?
Upgrading to a combi boiler may involve a significant cost increase, typically ranging from £800 to £1200 extra. However, switching to an A-rated combi boiler can save users up to 40 per cent on energy bills. Installing a combi boiler often necessitates system upgrades, such as replacing old gas pipes with larger ones to accommodate increased demand.
Despite the initial cost, the long-term savings on energy bills and the space-saving benefits make combi boilers an attractive option for many homeowners.
Combi boilers are often suited for small homes due to their compact size and the absence of a separate water tank. The size of your home is fundamental when upgrading to a combi boiler.
Common reasons for replacing a conventional boiler with a combi boiler include saving space, reducing costs, and increasing efficiency. If you have an old boiler and are looking to upgrade, a combi boiler can offer significant advantages.
Ready to make the switch? Request your free boiler installation quote today and let Future Heat help you choose the right solution for your home.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
The primary differences between combi boilers and conventional boilers lie in space requirements and operational mechanics; combi boilers are compact and heat water on demand, whereas conventional boilers necessitate separate storage tanks and can serve multiple outlets at once. Therefore, your choice may depend on available space and hot water needs.
Yes, combi boilers are generally more energy-efficient than conventional boilers, achieving efficiency ratings of 90 to 94 per cent compared to around 55 per cent for older conventional systems. A boost in efficiency can also be attributed to combi boilers being condensing, as a condensing boiler and combi boiler are pretty much the same thing. This results in significantly reduced energy waste.
When choosing between a combi boiler and a conventional boiler, it is essential to consider your home’s size, hot water demands, available space, installation costs, and potential long-term energy savings. Combi boilers are ideal for smaller homes, whereas conventional boilers are more suitable for larger residences with multiple bathrooms.
Combi boilers typically last between 10 and 15 years, while conventional boilers may last slightly longer, around 15 to 20 years. Proper maintenance is essential to maximise their lifespan and efficiency.
Yes, you can replace a conventional boiler with a combi boiler, and despite the potentially higher initial installation cost, the long-term energy savings and space-saving advantages make it a worthwhile investment.
Our Verdict
To wrap things up, choosing between a combi boiler and a conventional boiler depends on various factors, including the size of your home, hot water demands, and available space. Combi boilers are ideal for smaller homes with limited space, offering instant hot water and energy efficiency.
They are easier to install and maintain, making them a cost-effective option for many homeowners. However, they may struggle with multiple simultaneous hot water demands and rely on good mains water pressure.
Conventional boilers, on the other hand, are better suited for larger homes with multiple bathrooms and high hot water demands.
They provide a consistent supply of hot water to multiple outlets simultaneously but require more space for storage tanks and cylinders.
While they may be less efficient than modern combi boilers, their ability to handle high hot water demands makes them a reliable choice.
Ultimately, the right boiler for your home will depend on your specific needs and preferences. Consider all the factors discussed in this blog post to make an informed decision that ensures comfort, efficiency, and cost savings.
Myles Robinson is a seasoned expert in the boiler and home improvement industry, with over a decade of experience. He is deeply committed to environmental sustainability, actively promoting energy-efficient heating solutions to help households reduce their carbon footprint. By combining industry expertise with a dedication to environmental responsibility, Myles continues to lead efforts in transforming home heating practices towards a more sustainable future.
